home about photos slide shows videos magicsauce twitter other blogs books contact









If You Love To Write

Cool Social Media Tools

Analyst Blogs

Around The World

On Spirit & Philosophy

On Culture & Food

On Marketing & PR

On Economics and More

On Fashion

All Things Green

Dance Links

Books: Life

Books: Novels

Website Links

FAVORITE QUOTES

  • Only Those Who See the Invisible, Can Do The Impossible
  • The Age of your Heart is the Age of what you Love - Marcel Prévost
  • Tell me and I'll forget. Show me and I may remember. Involve me and I'll understand.
  • When one door of happiness closes, another opens; but often we look so long at the closed door that we don't see the one opening before us. -Helen Keller
  • The sole meaning of life is to serve humanity. -Leo Tolstoy
  • Nothing makes us so lonely as our secrets. -Paul Tournier
  • They may forget what you said, but they will never forget how you made them feel. -Carl W. Buechner
  • Just trust yourself, then you will know how to live. -Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
  • The foolish reject what they see, the wise reject what they think
  • Imagination is more important than knowledge - Albert Einstein
  • When you realize nothing is lacking, the whole world belongs to you - Lao-tzu
  • The world surrenders to a quiet mind
  • It is a funny thing about life: If you refuse to accept anything but the best you very often get it - Somerset Maugham
  • "At the moment of commitment, the universe conspires to assist you." Goethe


July 19, 2010

The Age Old Debate: 'Form vs. Function'

Which aspect of web development should hold more weight: the design or the functionality?

Are you more inclined to remember a site that is visually exciting or one that gets things done? Well, that depends on the audience, the brand and the intended message.

You are not likely to need your online bank to have pretty bells and flashy whistles, as long as it helps you make informed decisions and secured transactions with the least amount of headache. You don't go to a banking website to be entertained. You go to get things done. Banks (and their web developers) know this. Is it then not part of the design in developing the site to be focused on being functional rather than being a pretty page?

Function or form. Like art or commerce, beauty or brains, maybe 'or' is the problem, not the words on either side. After all, you wouldn't do an ad campaign and ask 'should we make it look nice, or get the messaging right? Likewise, food packaging doesn’t either look nice or contain the product. When comparing design or functionality in the digital world, one is not necessarily better than the other.

Around the office, we came to agree that form often is function (and visa versa), especially in digital comms and advertising. What we typically refer to as ‘design’ over functionality is actually more a form of ‘art’ so the question then boils more down to ‘design vs. art’ rather than ‘design vs. functionality’. A common definition of art is that it is the process of deliberately arranging elements in a way to affect the senses or emotions. For sites that are used for brand awareness/brand engagement (typically consumer brands), the appeal of appearance is more heavily weighted, with the functional purpose of the site taking second place.

Thinking of digital in terms of traditional media, the term ‘website’ could be the equivalent of the term ‘book’. In which case, how do the different styles of traditional book (eg. brochure, sales leaflet, encyclopedia, art book, etc.) directly relate to the different styles of website? An encyclopedia is designed to function as source of knowledge whereas a brochure or sales leaflet is typically designed to be visually appealing first, informative second. Do you want your brand’s site be a brochure or an encyclopedia?

One specific example which, whilst highly functional has also been very design-led and heavily analyzed to create the successful site it is today. Basecamp is a project management tool used by some major B2B companies and consumer brands (such as Kellogg’s and Warner Bros.). The tool’s straightforwardness makes it extremely user friendly and intuitive whilst remaining very functionally sound and clever.

The objective was to design it in such a manner that the function would overtake the design and make it seamless. This particular example points out how design can make something functional, intuitive and engaging.

Another good case study compares the usability (beyond the visual appeal) of the Apple and Microsoft websites. It’s well worth a look here.

So, function or form is no longer a matter of ‘or’, but ‘and’: Function and form, brains and beauty. AND, the two inseparable words if you intend to maintain a successful business, sell and deliver.

What do you think? Is a website's design its visual appeal or its functional intent?

July 19, 2010 in America The Free, Arts & Creative Stuff, Europe, On Branding, On Innovation, On Technology, PR & Marketing, United Kingdom, Web/Tech | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBack


PARTNERS

KUDOS

Recent Posts

  • Wisdom from Michael Pollan
  • Reflecting on Tony Hsieh's Death
  • The Coronavirus: A Spiritual Perspective!
  • Zen 2.0 Brings Connectedness & Compassion to Kamakura Japan
  • IONS Annual Conference Brings Together Scientists & Spiritual Seekers Under One Roof
  • On Discipline & the Art of Courage
  • Simplifying Your Life Connects you to Your Life Purpose
  • Gratitude & Remembering America's Core Values Will Set Us Free
  • In Honor of International Women's Day
  • Proposed Cut of Planned Parenthood Funding by New Administration

Forbes Top 50





Favorite Blog Posts

Conferences & Events

    2012 Archives

    January 2012

    February 2012

    March 2012

    April 2012

    May 2012

    June 2012

    July 2012

    August 2012

    September 2012
    October 2012
    November 2012

    December 2012


    All Archives
Featured on BlogHer.com

Categories

  • America The Free
  • Arts & Creative Stuff
  • Belize
  • Books
  • Client Announcements
  • Client Media Kudos
  • Conference Highlights
  • Current Affairs
  • Entertainment/Media
  • Europe
  • Events
  • Fiji
  • Holidays
  • Humor
  • In the News
  • Israel
  • Magic Sauce Media
  • Music
  • New England
  • New York
  • On Africa
  • On Australia
  • On Being Green
  • On Blogging
  • On Branding
  • On China
  • On Costa Rica
  • On Dance
  • On East Africa
  • On Education
  • On Fashion
  • On Fiji
  • On Food & Wine
  • On France
  • On Geo-Location
  • On Germany
  • On Guatemala
  • On Health
  • On India
  • On Innovation
  • On Italy
  • On Japan
  • On Journalism
  • On Mobile & Wireless
  • On Money
  • On Nature
  • On People & Life
  • On Poems, Literature & Stuff
  • On Politics
  • On Robotics
  • On RSS
  • On Science
  • On Search
  • On Social CRM
  • On South Africa
  • On Spain
  • On Spirituality
  • On Technology
  • On the Future
  • On Video
  • On VoIP
  • On Women
  • Photography
  • PR & Marketing
  • Reflections
  • Religion
  • San Francisco
  • Science
  • Social Gigs & Parties
  • Social Media
  • South America
  • Sports
  • Travel
  • TravelingGeeks
  • United Kingdom
  • Videos
  • WBTW
  • Web 2.0
  • Web/Tech
  • Weblogs

Subscribe


  • Add to Pageflakes

  • Add to Google

  • Add to Netvibes

  • Subscribe with Bloglines

  • Subscribe in NewsGator Online

  • Add to My! Yahoo

  • FeedBurner



Add me to your TypePad People list

Enter your Email


Powered by FeedBlitz

Copyright 1999-2022 Renee Blodgett